
Image: Rothco · source
Rothco Hickory Stripe Engineer Cap
Rothco · Budget
A heavyweight cotton railroad-engineer cap in the traditional blue and white hickory stripe, from a family-owned supplier of work and military clothing.
Carhartt · Budget
The Carhartt Iconic A18 Watch Cap Beanie is a 100% acrylic rib-knit cap with a fold-up cuff and a Carhartt patch, sold in one size.
Check price on Amazon (affiliate link, opens Amazon in a new tab)As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. How we pick our gear
We have not tested it ourselves: strengths and weaknesses below come from the tests cited.
Railfans spend their time outdoors, on platforms, at trackside viewpoints and at depots, and a knit cap is part of the clothing for it. Carhartt's own description of this cap says that it was originally designed as a workwear essential and is found at construction sites and campgrounds, state fairs and football stadiums. The page makes no claim about railways or about a warmth level. What the page does state is the construction: 100% acrylic rib knit with a fold-up cuff.
The cuff is the practical detail. The manufacturer lists a fold-up cuff, so the cap can be worn folded or unfolded, and the Carhartt patch sits on the cuff. It is sold in one size, labelled OS on the page, so there is nothing to choose except colour. The Black variant is a plain dark cap, and the manufacturer's photograph of it shows the cuffed shape and the patch. Carhartt's page does not state a temperature range, a lining, or any water resistance, so none is claimed here, and a parent or buyer who needs a specific level of cold protection should look at other garments. It is the style the manufacturer previously sold as the Acrylic Watch Hat, and the manufacturer says it stands behind the quality of its products through repair, replacement or credit.
Strengths
Weaknesses
| Specification | Value |
|---|---|
| Cuff | Fold-up cuff with Carhartt patch |
| Size | OS (one size) |
| Brand | Carhartt |
| Style | A18 |
| Material | 100% acrylic rib knit |
| Model No. | A18 |
| Country of origin | Imported |
| Colour (this entry) | Black |
Someone who wants a plain knit cap for outdoor days at the platform end, a trackside viewpoint or a depot visit, and who is happy with a cap whose maker describes it by materials and construction rather than by a stated warmth level. It also works as a simple present for an adult, in a colour that is easy to match. The colour selector on Carhartt's page lists sixteen colours, among them Black, Navy, Brite Orange, Brite Lime, Heather Gray and Dusty Olive, and the page notes that custom and bulk orders are available for businesses.
Carhartt's own page offers a Tonal Patch Beanie as the similar option for anyone for whom the colour they want is unavailable. Its details were not read for this entry.

Image: Rothco · source
Rothco · Budget
A heavyweight cotton railroad-engineer cap in the traditional blue and white hickory stripe, from a family-owned supplier of work and military clothing.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. How we pick our gear
Compare all apparel & caps.